Horigan`s Tavern in Elmira

365 Davis St, Elmira, NY 14901-2686, Elmira

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Bar
  • Pub
  • Irish
  • Vegetarian Friendly

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Do you have fish on Friday?

They did when we went a few days ago. My girlfriend who loves fish fry was wowed

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Horigan`s Tavern
PB
Phillip Brodginski
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Great food, great drinks, excellent atmosphere.

Horigan`s Tavern
WF
William Freeman
google
10.21.2018
4/5

Food terrific. Nice atmosphere. Nice people.

Horigan`s Tavern
AP
Andy Parker
google
10.15.2018
4/5

The new owners have done a very nice job adding life to a historic property, keeping the best parts of the past and adding several new twists.

Horigan`s Tavern
KR
Kayla Rohl
google
10.03.2018
1/5

We were in the area and decided to stop in for lunch. There was a "blackened prime rib sandwich" which by all means we love blackened food but this was burnt and had no taste. The prime rib was literally two centimeters thick, served with a few pieces of spinach and a piece of tomato. The best thing going for it was the hamburger roll it was served on. My delicious sandwich was served with a side of sour coleslaw which started to curdle. I would have loved to tell the waitress or anyone willing to listen how my food was but no one ever even came over to ask. Sadly the special of the day left a bad taste in our mouths, and no refills to wash it done.

Horigan`s Tavern
AC
Alison Callahan
google
09.25.2018
5/5

Great fish fry tonight. Beer selection good. Service exceptional.

Horigan`s Tavern
TE
Teresa Empson
google
09.03.2018
5/5

This was our first time and we were very pleasantly surprised. The soup was delicious, the portions were large and the bartender made an awesome margarita! So worth the stop!

Horigan`s Tavern
JW
Jamie Wirick
google
08.06.2018
5/5

A quant little bar. The service is awesome and the food was delicious

Horigan`s Tavern
SS
Sue Skidmore
google
07.24.2018
5/5

Great neighborhood bar restaurant. GOod live Music and hearty food.

Horigan`s Tavern
AW
Adam Wheeler
google
07.24.2018
5/5

Great food, live jazz on Wednesdays. Open for lunch!

Horigan`s Tavern
HS
Helen Spaulding
google
07.13.2018
1/5

We were with a large group (14 people) not one person said that would go back. Several things stand out ,1. it was very loud, with the lack of decor there was nothing to soften sound.2. Very limited menu, with prices that made it expensive.3. Way too limited on the beverage choices, ended up ordering coffee no spoon. Had to stir with my fork. 4. Most of my group were not overly impressed with the quality of the food. ( I had a Ruben it was good)5. Ok so we were in a group, so the tip was included. However they added all 14 persons tabs together came up with one total which they then divided by 14. Now I know that what I ordered was more than they charged, so somebody paid for part of my meal. Overall not impressed, and neither were the rest of my group.

Horigan`s Tavern
Zell
google
07.06.2018
4/5

Great food and pub like atmosphere! Trivia nights are fun and entertaining.

Horigan`s Tavern
TP
The Packards
google
06.03.2018
5/5

Great atmosphere and a great menu always equal a winner

Horigan`s Tavern
TR
Thomas Reilly
google
05.12.2018
4/5

Lunch there almost every week day for years now. The chef is very creative. The staff very personable and attentive. Kate is great. And they finally got a new popcorn maker.

Horigan`s Tavern
CB
Carl Brodginski
google
05.12.2018
4/5

Food is of great quality here. Has that sort of community cornerstone feel. Great beer/wine selection as well.

Horigan`s Tavern
LV
Lindsey Vedder
google
04.21.2018
5/5

Always love the food. Unfortunately, the best times to go are always really busy (St. Patricks day is the busiest!). I just went for the Alive at 5 concert and it was a fantastic time.

Horigan`s Tavern
ES
Eileen Spencer
google
04.05.2018
5/5

Good fish fry and Sheppard pie. Great coffee and service

Horigan`s Tavern
LR
Lor Roblyer
google
03.24.2018
5/5

My absolute favorite place !!! The food is so good and the Owner ..love Katie!!!

Horigan`s Tavern
AM
Alessandro Medici
google
02.14.2018
5/5

Elmira cocktail bar!

Horigan`s Tavern
JH
Joyce Hayduk
google
01.17.2018
5/5

Very good food and service! Not the best part of town

Horigan`s Tavern
TS
Tim Sweeney
google
01.05.2018
5/5

First time for me, second time for my wife. Food was very good as well as the service. I had the pot roast and potatoes, while she had the crab cakes. No complaints. Given that it was Saturday at around six, they weren't packed. Overall, I would recommend it.

Horigan`s Tavern
HM
Holly Mosher
google
09.11.2017
1/5

Had a terrible lunch. My chicken caesar wrap was hot so the lettuce was wilted and slimy. And it took 45 mins to get my food.

Horigan`s Tavern
BB
Ben Blonder
google
09.02.2017
5/5

Excellent calamari, excellent service, loved the environment. True Irish pub. Will be back!

Horigan`s Tavern
MC
Mary Cox
google
08.24.2017
1/5

So sad to say it because I usually enjoy the atmosphere here and have been coming for years, but the service/food the last three times has been beyond poor. Even when pointed out (and could have been made better) the attitude was "oh well too bad for you." Will not return.

Horigan`s Tavern
Kinglizard
google
07.27.2017
5/5

Great place to hang out. A pleasant ambiance with live music booked frequently and very good cuisine.

Horigan`s Tavern
PG
Patricia Gush
google
07.09.2017
5/5

Busy but it is great seeing people enjoying good food and drinks!!

Horigan`s Tavern
DL
Diane Lantz
google
06.26.2017
4/5

The French onion soup is awesome. Highly recommend

Horigan`s Tavern
DS
Dean Starke
google
06.06.2017
5/5

My first time there. The grilled steak salad was very good. French onion soup de-lish.

Horigan`s Tavern
DC
Denis Cole
google
05.27.2017
3/5

Nice atmosphere...food could have been better and service should have been better..

Horigan`s Tavern
CC
Carmen Chase
google
05.19.2017
5/5

Excellent food, comfortable atmosphere and good prices!

Horigan`s Tavern
SM
Sandra Moneymaker
google
04.26.2017
5/5

Good simple food and friendly staff.

Horigan`s Tavern
CT
Connie Taddeo
google
04.08.2017
4/5

Wonderful food. Loved the French onion soup. Other hor dourves were great. French fries were delicious. Will definitely be going bsck

Horigan`s Tavern
JG
Jill Gardner
google
02.04.2017
5/5

Great time with great friends, food, drinks and services were awesome! Large party to attend to. Our waitress was great. Didn't come around too much or too little.

Horigan`s Tavern
LB
Laura Briggs
google
01.23.2017
5/5

Great salads and sandwiches. Relaxing setting. Beautiful bar! Love this place.

Horigan`s Tavern
JK
John Kohena
google
09.02.2016
5/5

Beverage and food served was really good, as always. Yum! Server was appropriately attentive.

Horigan`s Tavern
DB
David Bishop
google
07.25.2016
4/5

One of the best local pubs. Great burgers, wraps and French onion soup. Their Reuben is the best

Horigan`s Tavern
MC
Micky Cavanaugh
google
07.17.2016
3/5

I want to love this place, but 3 out of the 4 times I've been, there has been something wrong with my food order and the wait staff has been inattentive... Good atmosphere though.

Horigan`s Tavern
MT
Mike Timonin
google
06.20.2016
4/5

Good place for lunch; a little loud around dinner time. Decent beer selection, and free popcorn at the bar. I recommend the fries with gravy and the burgers.

Horigan`s Tavern
AM
Amy Montondo
google
06.10.2016
4/5

Always have a great meal. Favorites are the pecan chicken, fish fry and prime rib on Saturday.

Horigan`s Tavern
CT
Carol Tapia
google
05.15.2016
5/5

A town classic. What's to complain about? Always feel at home there. Best coconut shrimp in the hemisphere. It's a family place.

Horigan`s Tavern
MT
Michael Taylor
google
05.09.2016
5/5

Very good food, excellent wait staff, free popcorn

Horigan`s Tavern
Daves
google
05.09.2016
5/5

Awesome wings and Reubens. Guiness on draught

Horigan`s Tavern
SC
Shanika Clark
google
04.17.2016
5/5

Food was great. I was pleasantly surprised to see vegetarian options although not advertised. We went on a night there were live jazz musicians. The ambience was terrific. Waitstaff was prompt and attentive. the margaritas were awesome. I can't wait to go again...UPDATE.....sadly they closed down I heard due to retirement of owner. Hopefully someone will buy it and keep it like it was.

Horigan`s Tavern
JK
Jim Ketcham
google
02.26.2016
4/5

I've always enjoyed the food here. Decent variety of beer on tap. Shepherd's Pie, fish fry, burgers all great. Free popcorn! Wait staff can be inattentive, especially when it's busy. If you want the fish fry on Fridays during Lent, go early, or be prepared to have a couple beers while you wait for a table. Seafood specials are always good, as well - although a bit pricey for my budget.

Horigan`s Tavern
JF
Joshua Forrest
google
02.24.2016
5/5

Great food at a great price. Everything from fried foods to grilled Salmon or Scallop dinners. The Reubens are the best in town bar none. Freshly cooked corned beef, crisp rye bread, the perfect amount of melted swiss make for a great lunch, dinner or late night snack. Trivia night every Thursday is always a blast.

Horigan`s Tavern
PM
Patricia Mosher
google
02.18.2016
3/5

Went to meet some friends who were in town and wanted to find a quiet place to have some drinks. Major problem was it was trivia night and extremely noisy. So if you are looking for a semi-quiet place for dining do not go here on a Thursday night.

Horigan`s Tavern
DM
Darren Mongardi
google
02.14.2016
4/5

Great pub! Always a hot tasty meal, great service and reasonable prices. Off the beaten path, but so worth finding! I think District Radio plays here...

Horigan`s Tavern
Marc
google
02.07.2016
5/5

Great meal and service all the way through. Beer selection is great too.

Horigan`s Tavern
TJ
Tom Jerram
google
01.25.2016
5/5

Good food reasonable prices. Pub atmosphere.

Horigan`s Tavern
JH
Jan Hill
google
01.14.2016
4/5

Always good food, generous portions, and friendly service.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 16077326625

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!